City Divided Over Tech’s Clout In San Francisco

Listen Now Download

Share this story:

Plans for 4500 residential units in the Mid-Market area, near Twitter's new building.
Plans for 4500 residential units in the Mid-Market area, near Twitter’s new building.

Silicon Valley may be the financial center of the tech industry, but lately San Francisco is earning a reputation as the heart and soul of it. Tech workers who don’t want to live in the Valley’s sprawling suburbs have migrated northward. And hundreds of tech-related businesses have set up shop in San Francisco too. But the culture of tech that’s taking hold in the city hasn’t come without controversy.

If you’re a young professional employed by one of the big tech companies, contemporary San Francisco is a carnival of delights. On a given weekend, you might choose from the soft opening of a high end neighborhood grocery store; a pricey music festival rollicking through landmark city parks; or a party for a podcasting startup at a tri-level downtown club. Thousands of tech workers live in vibrant neighborhoods like San Francisco’s Mission District, and commute in corporate shuttles to their jobs in Silicon Valley.

Just a couple of miles away, there’s a neighborhood where all of this growth has been conspicuously absent – the Tenderloin District. A quarter of Tenderloin residents live under the poverty line. Social service centers are clustered in this neighborhood, alongside drug activity, and immigrant families who can’t afford most other areas.

SF Gentrification 2.0 — For Better or Worse? from Turnstyle Video on Vimeo.

Walk a few blocks, and you hit a stretch of Market Street, San Francisco’s main thoroughfare, that’s also been untouched by growth, until recently. Nearly two years ago, Twitter leased a building here. To get Twitter to stay, and grow,  in San Francisco, the city gave the company tax breaks on its stock options and payroll.

Twitter’s press office didn’t respond to requests for comment, but there are plenty of other people talking up the potential transformation the company could bring to this moribund stretch of Market Street.

“The youthful energy that comes with a project like this — or any place where you’re going to put 7,000 employees on a city block that’s been essentially vacant for a decade — will create an energy for the area that we haven’t seen here,” said Tom McDonnell, VP of Leasing for Shorenstein. The development firm renovated this art deco building for Twitter, and other tech companies followed, renting space near “the cool kids.” Microsoft’s Yammer is here.  So is the online retailer One King’s Lane. Forty-five-hundred residential units will soon go up near Twitter’s headquarters.

“That building jacked up the rents astronomically,” said writer and Tenderloin resident Joseph Thomas. “All my merchant friends on Market Street, two or three of them are out of business.” Thomas says the neighborhood is becoming unaffordable for middle and low income residents.

San Francisco Board of Supervisors President David Chiu says the explosion of the tech sector is directly responsible for a positive change: “Our budget deficit today is a quarter of what it was four years ago.” Welcoming companies like Twitter here, says Chiu, brought in revenue that allows San Francisco to strengthen its social safety net — access to homeless and mental health services, child care, at risk youth programs.

Another ripple effect Chiu cites –job creation.  The Bay Area Council Economic Institute found that for every new tech industry job, four non-tech jobs opened up.

Critics say those new jobs aren’t necessarily good-enough jobs.

Shortt says many of San Francisco’s bus drivers or janitors have already been priced out of living in the city where they work – and more will follow.

For many people born and raised in San Francisco, its new economy is at odds with the city’s reputation for progressive social change.  For many people whom tech has delivered here, the city’s future is bright.

The mid-Market area is only  the latest neighborhood where how much money you have may determine whether you get to stay.

SF Native Joseph Thomas says the city is becoming unaffordable for the working class.

Listen Now